Mailchimp AI Review
AI add-on for an aging email platform
The Honest Take
Mailchimp is Playing Catch-Up
Mailchimp bolted AI features onto an email platform that was already losing ground to newer competitors like ConvertKit and Beehiiv. The AI-generated content is passable but not great. Send time optimization is the best feature. If you’re on Mailchimp already, the AI helps. But it’s not a reason to choose Mailchimp over better alternatives.
Mailchimp’s pricing has also gotten worse over the years, making it a harder sell compared to creator-focused platforms.
What Is Mailchimp AI?
Mailchimp is primarily an email marketing platform that recently added AI capabilities. The AI features include:
- AI Subject Line Generator: Suggests email subject lines to improve open rates
- Send Time Optimization: AI determines the best time to send emails to each subscriber
- Content Suggestions: AI recommends email content ideas
- Subscriber Insights: AI analyzes subscriber behavior and preferences
- Campaign Analytics AI: Breakdown of what drove performance
These are bolted onto Mailchimp’s broader email platform, which you’re paying for regardless of whether you use the AI.
Pricing Breakdown
Mailchimp’s pricing has become less competitive. The free tier is limited, and you need paid plans to access AI features.
Essentials
- Unlimited contacts
- Email marketing
- Basic AI included
- Standard reports
Standard
- All Essentials
- Full AI features
- Send optimization
- Advanced reports
Premium
- All Standard features
- SMS marketing
- Custom workflows
- Priority support
Real talk: Standard ($20/mo) is the minimum to access full AI features. Free tier is too limited for professional use. Premium ($350/mo) is expensive and most users don’t need the extra features.
Pros vs Cons
Advantages
- Send time optimization works well
- Subject line generator is useful
- Basic content suggestions save time
- Integrated into familiar interface
- Affordable entry price ($13-$20/mo)
Disadvantages
- AI content quality is mediocre
- Best features locked behind Standard tier
- Mailchimp pricing has gotten worse
- Competitors (ConvertKit, Beehiiv) better for creators
- Analytics AI is basic
Who Should Use Mailchimp AI?
Best For:
- Existing Mailchimp users wanting AI assistance
- Small businesses with basic email needs
- Budget-conscious teams who want AI features
- Non-profits and low-revenue organizations
Skip If:
- You’re choosing an email platform from scratch
- You’re a creator — ConvertKit or Beehiiv are better
- You want world-class AI writing — use ChatGPT instead
- You need advanced segmentation and automation
How Mailchimp Compares
Mailchimp AI
- Affordable entry
- Send optimization works
- Basic AI content
- Traditional email focused
- Aging platform
vs ConvertKit
- ConvertKit better for creators
- ConvertKit has better UI
- Mailchimp cheaper
- ConvertKit more features
- Both have AI now
vs Beehiiv
- Beehiiv more modern
- Beehiiv better referral tools
- Mailchimp has longer history
- Beehiiv for newsletters
- Different use cases
vs HubSpot
- HubSpot more features
- HubSpot much more expensive
- Mailchimp focused on email
- HubSpot broader platform
- Mailchimp better for email
Features Deep Dive
Send Time Optimization — Best Feature
This is Mailchimp’s strongest AI feature. The system analyzes each subscriber’s behavior to determine the best time to send them emails. It actually works and can improve open rates by 10-20%.
The only catch: it requires historical data. New lists won’t see benefits for a few weeks.
AI Subject Line Suggestions
When composing an email, Mailchimp suggests subject lines based on your email content. The suggestions are decent but often generic. Better than nothing, but not as creative as ChatGPT.
Content Suggestions
AI recommends email content based on your industry and subscriber data. The suggestions are basic and often obvious. “Add a call-to-action” — yes, we know.
Subscriber Insights
AI analyzes which subscribers are most engaged and which are likely to unsubscribe. Useful for list hygiene. You can automatically move inactive subscribers to a separate list.
Campaign Analytics AI
After sending, AI provides a breakdown of what drove performance. Identifies which elements resonated with your audience. Helpful but basic compared to dedicated analytics tools.
Frequently Asked Questions
+
It depends on your use case. For creators and newsletters, ConvertKit or Beehiiv are better. For traditional email marketing, Mailchimp is fine but not exceptional. The AI is a bonus, not a reason to choose it.
+
No. The content suggestions are basic and often generic. Use ChatGPT or Jasper for AI content generation, then paste into Mailchimp. Separate tools do it better.
+
Send time optimization is Mailchimp’s best AI feature. It can improve open rates by 10-20% if your list is large enough. Requires several weeks of historical data to work well.
+
The free tier is limited to 500 contacts and basic email only. AI features are not available. You need at least Standard ($20/mo) for full AI features.
+
For creators and newsletters, ConvertKit is better. For traditional email marketing, Mailchimp is fine. ConvertKit has better features for growth and monetization. Both have AI now.
Final Verdict
Bottom line: Mailchimp’s AI features are decent add-ons to a traditional email platform. Send time optimization actually works. But the AI content generation is mediocre, and there are better alternatives.
If you’re already on Mailchimp, use the AI features to save time. But if you’re choosing a new email platform, look at ConvertKit (for creators) or Beehiiv (for newsletters) first. Both are more modern and better suited for growing audiences.
Mailchimp’s problem is that it’s playing catch-up. It was the leader, but newer platforms have passed it.